Tuesday, June 2, 2020

Indian Culture



One example of an anthropological revisionism propagated by the Sangh Parivar is the claim that Indian culture as the exclusive property for a particular religion and calling it "Hindu Culture".

Let me be clear, every person on this planet holds his culture to be exceptional and dear to him, as he has every right to do. As a naturalized US citizen of Indian origin, I am proud of my Indian culture but do not claim cultural superiority. Anyone who claims cultural superiority needs to examine how that worked out in Europe during the Nazi regime.

Cultures are not homogeneous, cultures have influenced each other and evolved from the beginning of time. The inclusiveness of the Indian Culture has led to influences from Invaders, traders, and travelers to find it's way into it. Indian culture absorbed some Persian and Mughal influences even though they were Invaders who looted and plundered the land. This can be best captured by the below quote.

"I do not want my house to be walled in on all sides and my windows to be stuffed. I want the cultures of all lands to be blown about my house as freely as possible. But I refuse to be blown off my feet by any" - Mahatma Gandhi (8)

No religion can claim a monopoly over the Indian culture that I accepted and follow, or attach it to a religion (whatever the religion may be). This is the culture of this land which many have voluntarily choose to accept it and live by. I consider the Albanian nun who dedicated her life to helping the dying on the streets of Kolkata more in line with "Indian Culture" than the goons who raped and plundered fellow citizens in Gujarat. Indian culture is not the sole property of the RSS, Congress, Muslim League, Kerala Congress or any other party or organization. I don't need any sangvi to lecture me on my beloved Indian culture nor do I need a certificate of Indianess from the Sangh Parivar. 

Culture is much older than religion and transcends religion. Culture should be a unifying rather than divisive factor. The moment we rename Indian culture as the exclusive property of one religion we let loose divisive tendencies that are myopic and destructive.

Like all cultures, Indian culture had it's weak moments too, it tolerated the evils of casteism and untouchability for too long. But was smart enough to correct itself and move forward. This change and assimilation is the hallmark of a culture that thrives as Gandhiji explained above.

Enough of the serious stuff, here are some interesting advanced linguistic gymnastics from Mrs. Shobha Surendran (Kerala - State General Secretary and a former national executive committee member of the party) (9). With leaders like these BJP does not need any opponents. 


Apologies to readers not familiar with Malayalam, it's hard to translate. Mrs. Shobha Surendran provided an interesting interpretation/translation of PM Modi's quote (2). She claimed that the PM was not referring to the patriot when he was alive. She entertained the whole panel as she continued to stick to her version.



Manorama News, Published on May 10, 2018 (10)

Shaheed Bhagat Singh the Patriot who selflessly sacrificed for India's freedom could be turning in his grave.


References & Footnotes
  1. Mahatma Gandhi (1980). “All Men are Brothers: Autobiographical Reflections”, p.142, A&C Black - https://www.azquotes.com/quote/484648
  2. Mrs. Shobha Surendran, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shobha_Surendran, State General Secretary (https://www.keralabjp.org/core-committee-members ) and a former national executive committee member of the party.
  3. Manorama News, published on YouTube on May 10, 2018 - https://youtu.be/d0EcyFYUVcw